ICE vs ice videos from Minnesota put the agency’s weaknesses on display

Minneapolis is currently inundated with two kinds of ice—both of which make it hard for residents to move about the city. 

The bone-chilling winter cold has left icy deposits on streets and sidewalks, while the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency has run roughshod over them in what the Department of Homeland Security calls “the largest DHS operation ever.”

As anyone who’s ever set booted foot in Minnesota in winter can attest, gravity and overconfidence are no match for one of the world’s most slippery surfaces. Given the abundance of cameras that tend to follow ICE agents, it was perhaps inevitable that there would be multiple viral videos of agents absolutely biffing it on literal ice throughout the Twin Cities. The surging popularity of these videos, though, suggests ICE’s critics are getting a lot more out of them than cold comfort.

Midwestern progressives may have cheered such content no matter the context, but given recent events, the videos have taken on deeper resonance. Minneapolis has been at the center of a political firestorm since December, when President Trump seized on reports of social services fraud in the city, perpetrated in part by Somali Americans, to denigrate the area’s entire deeply rooted Somali community.

On January 6, DHS announced it was deploying as many as 2,000 agents into the city to crack down on fraud and, of course, undocumented immigrants. By the following afternoon, an agent had shot and killed Renee Nicole Good in broad daylight.

In the days since Good’s killing, tensions have erupted in Minneapolis and rippled across the country. Massive protests have sprung up throughout the Twin Cities, as well as from New York City to Portland, Oregon. Local politicians and national figures like Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have called out Trump for lying about what happened to Good, while Minnesota and Illinois have sued his administration to block the surge of federal agents.

For now, though, the DHS incursion into Minnesota continues, disrupting the normal flow of day-to-day life in the Twin Cities. ICE is reportedly conducting door-to-door raids in some areas, and in one highly publicized incident, agents violently detained two U.S. citizens, one of whom is 17 years old, while they were working a shift at Target. (Both were later released, reportedly with injuries.)

After agents started showing up at local schools, several districts have switched to remote learning. Some restaurants have closed their doors indefinitely, while touring acts have postponed shows in the city, citing the welfare of attendees. In fact, the only people who seem to want to visit Minneapolis at the moment are MAGA influencers hoping to squeeze some content out of the carnage.

Given the dark, authoritarian overtones of DHS’s citywide siege, it’s no wonder viewers are rejoicing in videos of ICE agents busting ass.

First, came the clip in which a pair of agents ate it on an icy sidewalk together, causing one of their rifles to discharge—thankfully hurting no bystanders. Then there was the video of an agent running down the street at full speed before hitting a slick thicket of ice, as captured from multiple angles. And let’s not forget the agents who apparently could not get any locals to help them unstick their car from a snowy curb and wobbled around doing so themselves. It’s all classic slapstick, practically begging for the Benny Hill theme song to be dubbed over it.

As these clips proliferate online, another genre of viral video has emerged out of Minneapolis in tandem—one that helps explain just what else the ice-fail videos are accomplishing. These videos could be called a learning series, since they depict agents approaching protesters and asking if they haven’t learned anything yet from recent events. (“Learned what?” a protester responds in one of the videos, before an agent smacks the phone out of her hand.)

These videos appear to illustrate ICE agents’ expectations: that anyone disapproving of them should be cowed into respect and obedience. If protesters remain unfazed instead and continue mouthing off, the agents seem to suggest, well, who knows what could end up happening? Perhaps the same fate that met Good when she proved insufficiently respectful and obedient. The president suggested as much in comments he made aboard Air Force One on Monday—evidence that the blasé attitude ICE agents have toward use of force comes right from the top. 

Beyond doling out barely veiled threats, the agents in these videos also toe the party line that ICE is made up of hypercompetent heroes unfairly victimized by violent rioters. All they want is to surgically expunge criminal scum from the city, which they would accomplish easily, if only a well-coordinated domestic terrorist network would stop weaponizing vehicles at them.

This is where the falling-down videos, and attendant memes, come in handy. These videos decidedly do not make ICE look like hypercompetent heroes. They make them look like the buffoons they are.  

They undercut the agents’ warrior self-mythology, reducing them to doofuses who don’t realize winter ice might mean an attack of the killer sidewalks. The gleeful spread of these embarrassing clips sends the same message as the D.C. sandwich-thrower last summer and the wave of inflatable animals at the “No Kings” protests last fall. They help defang the vast threat represented by masked agents of state, rendering them eminently fallible. And the popularity of the videos also contradicts the preposterous notion that, as Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino said on Fox News this week, “90% of the public are happy to see us.”

Sure, it’s a small victory, but one that offers a strong reminder to the public to believe their eyes, not the spin from the administration.

It might also help ensure that—whether from Minnesota’s natural elements or its fired-up citizenry—ICE agents will continue getting a chilly reception as long as they remain in the state. 

Have they not learned this lesson yet?

source https://www.fastcompany.com/91474345/minneapolis-ice-raids-videos-agents-falling